Should You Buy Or Rent With Your Next PCS?

The USAA Educational Foundation

Buying a house is a huge financial decision, and it’s even bigger for military families who could receive new PCS orders before the boxes are fully unpacked from the last move. So, if you’re in the military, should you buy or should you rent?

No One-Size-Fits All Answer

In short, there is no perfect answer. Each house, family, and real estate market will be different. But here are five questions that could help you decide if the timing is right for homeownership or if renting makes more sense:

1. Do you have an emergency fund?

Maintaining an emergency fund makes good sense for almost everyone. Still, it’s even more important for homeowners because of the possible magnitude, importance, and unpredictability of home repair and maintenance expenses. If you don’t have an emergency fund equivalent to at least three months worth of expenses, perhaps buying a home should wait.

2. Do you follow a budget?

For most people, homeownership and budgets should go hand-in-hand. The better you are at managing your cash, the better prepared you’ll be to handle the financial challenges associated with owning a home.

3. Do you have a down payment saved up?

A down payment provides instant equity that can be a real life saver if the housing market hasn’t cooperated by the time you need to sell. Plus, the very act of being able to save up a down payment is often a good indicator you’ve got the financial discipline that can help make owning a home easier.

4. Do you have strong future job security?

Household expenses consume more than any other budget category for most people. Add in the long-term commitment of owning a home and it becomes clear just how important your future earning ability is if you’re going to buy. If you’ve got two household incomes try to budget your housing costs around just one of them to give you more security.

5. Do you have the ability to keep the house for a long time?

Every housing market is different but if you can't plan on owning a house for at least three years (sometimes a lot longer), renting might be the better move. For military personnel with three- or four-year assignments, this is an especially important point to consider.

Now to be completely fair, it’s worth noting that plenty of people have purchased homes without ever considering these questions and everything worked out just fine. Still, with a financial transaction this large, it’s typically better to think about it from as many angles as possible.

The USAA Educational Foundation, a nonprofit organization, does not endorse or promote any commercial supplier, product, or service.


Tip of the Day

  • Written by Guest Blogger | March 13, 2014

    Start an emergency fund by saving $10/week or $40/month to save $500 by the end of the year

Saver Stories View all »

When You Start Small, Saving is Easy

Written by Lila Quintiliani | August 12, 2019

When Attiyya first got married, she and her Marine husband had just graduated from college and were focused on paying off student loan debt. They had both attended private schools and had sizeable loans. Then three months after the wedding, the couple found out they were pregnant with their first child.

The first year of their marriage, says Attiyya, was a balancing act between paying down debt and saving for the future.


Money on the Side

Written by Super User | November 26, 2010

Camp Arifjan, Kuwait -- A colonel in the 1st Theater Sustainment Command has money on his mind.

Army Col. George Fields, the Chief of Intelligence, or G2, has been teaching a free "Managing Your Money" class here in his spare time. More than 400 students have attended his six week-long class to learn more about increasing their own finances.

"All I did was sit down and listen to a guy one day who showed me what he was doing" said the colonel as he explained how he became interested in what he calls, "becoming financially free."


One Sailor's Course to Financial Freedom

Written by Super User | November 26, 2010

We all know its not easy to get out of debt once you in over your head. But it can be done with the sound advice and support that the Military Saves program offers. I am a testament to that. I was a recently divorced, single mother. Like many people I had credit card debt, a car loan, bad credit, and a low income job that never seemed to be enough to put food on the table.

Then I decided I'd had enough of living paycheck to paycheck and worrying about money all the time.